Book club and discussion guide
Talk it over
Questions for groups reading The God Algorithm together. Start anywhere. Each part is closed until you open it, so nobody reads ahead by accident.
For the person leading
- Four meetings work well, one for each part below. One meeting works too: use the opening questions and a handful from part four.
- Let members know before they start that the book deals with a pastor's abuse of two children and a church that kept it quiet. It is never described in detail, but some readers will want to know ahead of time.
- Most groups have both believers and skeptics in them, whether they say so or not. The book tries to give both sides their strongest case. A good discussion does the same.
- For each Saturday world, the arguments page lists the real thinkers on both sides. Pick one and read it aloud before you discuss.
Opening questions
No spoilers. Good for a first meeting, or for anyone deciding whether to read it.
- The author's note says the book "takes on the arguments I believe most often move people toward belief in God, or away from it." Before you started, which way did you expect the book to lean? Did that change as you read?
- Which argument has moved you most in your own life, toward belief or away from it? Is it one of the Saturday worlds?
- Sam tests software for a living. He writes the rule down exactly, predicts what will happen, and sets his score before he runs a test. How does that habit help him argue about God? Where does it get in his way?
- The back cover calls this "a novel about doubt, honest argument, and the people who show up anyway." Which of those three did the book make you think about most?
Questions by part
The book has 23 chapters. This guide groups them into four parts for discussion.
Part one: The dare
Chapters 1 to 5 Spoilers through Chapter 5 Show questionsHide
The debate, the letter, the barn, and the first Saturdays: a world where no one can doubt, a world where no one can refuse, and a world where no one has to ask.
- Sam argues against God in public under another name. Why do you think he keeps that part of his life separate from his work and his family?
- Daniel's letter says only "Come and see." Why does Sam go? What would it have taken to get you down that gravel road?
- At the softball game Sam hands Owen, a shy boy on the bench who isn't his, the scorebook and teaches him to keep it. Why does a small kindness like that tell you so much about a narrator?
- After the first world, Daniel offers Pascal's idea of a dial: "Enough light to walk toward. Enough dark that the walking's yours." Sam answers that this is exactly what a world with no God in it would look like. Whose point lands harder for you?
- Augustine says the first people were "able not to sin" and the redeemed will be "not able to sin." What is the difference between goodness that is installed and goodness that is grown into? Does it matter?
- "Some prayers get answered with a person instead of an outcome." Has that been true in your experience?
- Kate leaves Sam the first voicemail she has ever left him. Why doesn't he call back?
Part two: The Saturdays
Chapters 6 to 10 Spoilers through Chapter 10 Show questionsHide
The padded world, the pardon world, and the ghost world, while Kate and Sam start, carefully, to talk.
- Sam sets the score before he runs each world, so he can't move the goalposts later. Would arguments in your family, church or workplace go differently if both sides did that?
- In the padded world no body can be hurt. What did you expect would happen to the people in it? What surprised you?
- Dwayne says, "I forgave him. It took me most of that year to do it. But I didn't give him the keys back." How is forgiving someone different from trusting them again?
- Marta's story in the pardon world asks who pays when nobody is ever held responsible. What did her kitchen show you about whether forgiveness can be free?
- Sam asks why a forgiving God would need a cross, and Daniel admits he can't make it come out even for him. Was that honesty more persuasive to you, or less, than a neat answer would have been?
- At the funeral in the ghost world, Ben asks whether his grandmother is coming back. "She's right there." "No. Back." What do grieving people actually want?
- Before he leaves the ghost world, Sam types a name and then deletes it. Why do you think he deletes it?
Part three: Closer to August
Chapters 11 to 17 Spoilers through Chapter 17 Show questionsHide
Hell, the lottery of birth, the Fourth of July, a Sunday at a small country church, and the animals, with Kate's day in August getting closer.
- Daniel reads the hardest passages about hell aloud, in full, "so neither of them picks the pretty pages." Why is that a fair way to argue? Do you do it?
- Sam and Daniel each make a prediction out loud before the hell world runs. What did you predict? What did the man the machine chose teach you about owing nothing to anyone?
- Sam names people he knows who are better than he is and believe less. Daniel answers with Genesis 18:25: "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do what is just?" Is that an answer, or a refusal to answer? Can it be both?
- What did the fair-start world show about what makes a person who they are? Where does Daniel admit his own view still limps?
- The couriers world is a test, not a repair, and Daniel can't find what it costs. Why won't Sam claim the win?
- At the Fourth of July cookout Sam's Saturdays and his family meet for the first time. What changes when Daniel meets Kate?
- Kate asks Sam for very little: a chair by the door, no speaking, and to stay until she is done. Why is it so hard for him to say yes?
- The animal world is Sam's "clean case," because animals don't choose. Which side of the debate about animal suffering do you find stronger?
- As August gets closer, Sam's work starts to slip. How does the book show you what he is carrying without spelling it out?
Part four: The end of summer
Chapters 18 to 23 For readers who have finished the book Show questionsHide
For groups who have read to the last page. Even here, please don't spoil the ending for anyone who hasn't.
- Which moment in the last chapters did you not see coming? Looking back, where had the book already been preparing you for it?
- The book deals with a pastor's abuse of two children and a church that kept it quiet, and it never describes the abuse. Why do you think the author made that choice? How did it affect you as a reader?
- The back cover promises "the people who show up anyway." Who shows up in the last part of the book, and for whom? Who has shown up like that in your life?
- How did the last chapter change the way you read the first one?
- This book is full of families that have gone quiet with each other. What does it take to rebuild a family after a long silence?
- The author's note says, "Read it, argue with it, and make up your own mind." Where have you landed? Which argument would you most like to put to Daniel, or to Sam?
Tell Mike what your group thought
If your group read the book together, Mike would love to hear what came up. You can also ask about joining your conversation.
Write to Mike